Hammer, claw, and mallet toes: causes and treatment solutions

Toe deformities, whether hammer, claw, or mallet toes, are common foot conditions that can impact both posture and overall foot comfort. Left untreated, these abnormalities may lead to pain, walking difficulties, and long-term complications.

Learn about the specific features of each condition, their underlying causes, symptoms, and the treatment options available to help relieve your discomfort.

What are hammer toes ? 

Hammer toes are a foot deformity in which one or more toes, most commonly the second or third, bend abnormally at the proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joint, creating a shape similar to the letter “Z”.

This abnormal curvature is often associated with pain on the top of the affected toe, mainly due to pressure from footwear. It frequently leads to the formation of corns. If not treated, the deformity can progress, causing increased discomfort and difficulty walking.

Illustration of hammer toes

Claw toes: understanding this foot deformity

Claw toes are characterized by excessive flexion of the toe joints, typically between the first and second phalanges, giving the toe a claw-like appearance. This type of deformity most commonly affects the last three toes.

Illustration of claw toes

Mallet toes: a less common but painful deformity

Mallet toes are less common but can cause significant discomfort. This deformity occurs when the toe bends at its tip, creating a mallet-like shape. It often leads to sharp pain, especially when the foot is subjected to pressure, such as when wearing tight or narrow shoes.

Illustration of mallet toes

What are the differences, and how can these toe deformities be identified?

While these three conditions may appear similar at first glance since they all alter toe alignment, they are distinguished by key anatomical differences. Depending on which joint is affected and how the toe bends, the condition is classified as a hammer toe, claw toe, or mallet toe.

These distinctions impact not only the visual appearance of the foot but also the location of pain, potential complications, and the appropriate treatment approach. To determine the most effective course of action, it is essential to consult a physician, a foot specialist, or undergo a comprehensive biomechanical assessment.

 

Symptoms of hammer toes, claw toes, and mallet toes

Toe deformities are relatively common and may result from muscular imbalances, abnormal foot loading, or underlying medical conditions. Once established, these deformities are often accompanied by characteristic symptoms that should not be ignored.

 

Symptoms of hammer toes and claw toes

  • Pain localized to the affected toe
  • Reduced mobility or pain during toe movement
  • Development of corns or calluses that may become irritated
  • Throbbing or discomfort in the forefoot during walking
  • Risk of joint dislocation if the deformity has been present for an extended period

 

Symptoms of mallet toes

  • Nail deformity
  • Occasional formation of a small corn
  • Irritation at the joint near the tip of the affected toe

Causes of hammer, claw, and mallet toes 

The causes of hammer, claw, and mallet toe deformities are often similar. They primarily stem from biomechanical imbalances, inappropriate footwear, or genetic predisposition.

 

  • Other foot pain, such as hallux valgus (a deformity of the big toe), can contribute to the development of toe deformities.

 

  • Biomechanical abnormalities, including flat feet or excessive pronation, may lead to uneven weight distribution across the toes, increasing the risk of structural deformities.

 

  • Wearing narrow or high-heeled shoes places excessive pressure on the toes, which can cause deformities to develop gradually over time. In addition, genetic factors may predispose certain individuals to these conditions.

 

While the symptoms associated with each type of deformity are generally similar, such as pain and difficulty walking, there may be specific characteristics depending on the type. For example, hammer toes typically involve pain on the top of the toe, whereas mallet toes may cause sensitivity at the tip of the toe.

Treatment for hammer, claw, and mallet toes

Treatment for these toe deformities typically begins with conservative approaches. This may include adjustments to daily habits such as rest, application of ice to reduce inflammation, and targeted physical therapy exercises to improve mobility and relieve pain.

However, if conservative methods prove insufficient, additional options may be considered depending on the severity of the deformity. In such cases, prevention plays a critical role, as treatment is primarily aimed at alleviating pain and halting the progression of the condition rather than fully reversing it.

 

Use of foot orthotics

Wearing foot orthotics can significantly relieve discomfort by providing optimal support and reducing friction between the toes and footwear. It is essential to select orthotics designed to redistribute pressure across the forefoot, particularly in cases of hammer, claw, or mallet toes. These orthotics often include a metatarsal dome that helps relieve pressure on the toe joints, preventing further deterioration and alleviating pain.

 

Choosing proper footwear

Footwear selection is a key factor in both treating and preventing toe deformities. Shoes should be anatomically supportive and reduce pressure on affected toes. It is recommended to choose shoes with a heel height of less than one inch and a thick, rocker-bottom sole. These features help minimize impact on the toes and ease the symptoms associated with deformity.

 

Considering foot surgery

Surgery is generally considered a last resort for the treatment of hammer, claw, and mallet toes, and is recommended only when conservative treatments have failed. The surgical procedure aims to correct the deformity by realigning the affected joints or, in some cases, removing part of the deformed toe. This allows for long-term pain relief and restoration of normal foot function.

 

Professional support for managing toe deformities

Toe deformities such as hammer, claw, and mallet toes can significantly impact your daily life by causing pain, discomfort, and difficulty walking. At Médicus, we understand how these conditions can affect your quality of life. With over 65 years of experience in podiatry and orthopedics, we are committed to providing personalized care tailored to your specific needs. Our expertise allows us to offer targeted treatments designed to relieve pain effectively and help prevent the progression of these deformities.

We combine custom-made foot orthotics, expert guidance on orthopedic footwear, and individualized follow-up to help you regain optimal comfort. Our approach focuses on enhancing your well-being so you can return to your daily activities without pain.